August vs Schlage Keyless Door Lock

August vs Schlage: Which Keyless Lock is Right for You?

August and Schlage are two of the most popular names in smart locks, but they take very different approaches. August focuses on retrofitting your existing deadbolt with a smart module, while Schlage offers a complete lock replacement with built-in security features. This comparison breaks down the key differences to help you decide.

Key Differences at a Glance

The fundamental difference is design philosophy. August locks are designed to be added to your existing single-cylinder deadbolt, making them ideal for renters or those who want to keep their current keys. Schlage locks replace the entire lock assembly, integrating the smart electronics directly into the lock body for a more seamless and secure experience.

Installation and Compatibility

August locks are incredibly easy to install. They simply replace the interior thumb turn of your existing deadbolt. This process takes about 10 minutes and requires only a screwdriver. This makes August a top choice for renters or anyone who wants to avoid a complex installation. However, it does require your existing deadbolt to be compatible, which most standard ones are.

Schlage locks require a full lock replacement. You remove your entire existing deadbolt and install the Schlage unit. This takes a bit longer (15-30 minutes) but ensures a perfect fit and integration. Schlage locks come with a built-in keyway, so you get a new set of keys. This is a better option for homeowners who want a complete upgrade.

Security and Build Quality

Schlage has a long-standing reputation for physical security. The Encode Plus is built with a solid metal construction and an ANSI Grade 1 rating, which is the highest residential security rating. The lock mechanism is robust and resistant to physical attacks. The built-in keyway is also pick-resistant.

August locks rely on the security of your existing deadbolt. While the deadbolt itself may be ANSI Grade 2 or 3, the August module adds smart features but does not upgrade the physical lock's security. The August lock is well-built, but the overall security depends on the deadbolt you already have. For maximum security, Schlage is the clear winner.

Smart Features and Ecosystem

Both locks support the major smart home platforms: Apple HomeKit, Amazon Alexa, and Google Assistant. The Schlage Encode Plus has an advantage with its built-in Thread radio, which allows it to connect directly to HomeKit over Thread for faster and more reliable performance. The August Wi-Fi Smart Lock uses standard Wi-Fi and Bluetooth.

August's app is often praised for its user-friendly interface and features like Auto-Unlock, which uses your phone's location to unlock the door automatically. Schlage's app is functional but less polished. However, Schlage offers built-in keypad access, which is a separate purchase for August. For a truly keyless experience, Schlage's built-in keypad is a major convenience.

Battery Life and Reliability

Schlage locks generally have better battery life, often lasting 6-12 months on a set of four AA batteries. The lock also provides low-battery warnings well in advance. August locks typically last 3-6 months, which is shorter but still acceptable. Both locks allow you to use a 9V battery on the exterior to power the lock if the internal batteries die.

Reliability is a key factor. Schlage locks are known for their consistent performance. The mechanical connection between the smart module and the lock is solid. August locks can sometimes have connectivity issues, especially with Wi-Fi, and the Auto-Unlock feature can occasionally be unreliable. Schlage's direct integration generally offers more predictable performance.

What to Check Before Buying

Before purchasing, check the compatibility of your door. Ensure your door is pre-drilled for a standard deadbolt (2-1/8 inch bore hole). For August, confirm your existing deadbolt is compatible (most are). For Schlage, measure the backset (2-3/8 or 2-3/4 inches) and door thickness (standard 1-3/8 to 1-3/4 inches). Also, verify your Wi-Fi signal strength at the door.

Mistakes to Avoid

A common mistake is not checking your door's preparation. Some doors have a non-standard bore hole that won't fit either lock. Another mistake is assuming all smart locks work with all smart home systems. While both August and Schlage support major platforms, always double-check compatibility with your specific hub. Finally, don't forget about the physical key. Schlage includes one, but August relies on your existing key, so you must keep that safe.