DeWalt vs Makita Band Saw
Choosing between a DeWalt and a Makita portable band saw means picking between two industry leaders known for rugged build and reliable performance. This comparison breaks down their cordless models to help you decide which brand fits your workflow and budget.
Quick answer
For raw cutting speed and a wider blade capacity, the DeWalt DCS374B is the top pick. For better ergonomics, longer runtime, and a lighter overall package, the Makita XBP04Z leads. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize brute force or all-day comfort.
Why trust ToolBuyerHub
- Tested on specs (power, torque, PSI)
- Battery & ecosystem compared
- Aggregated owner reviews
- Build quality & warranty checked
- Brand reliability
- No fake hands-on claims
Research updated June 2026.
| Feature | DeWalt DCS374B | Makita XBP04Z |
|---|---|---|
| Motor Type | Brushless | Brushless |
| Blade Speed (no load) | 245 / 295 SFPM (2-speed) | 200 / 280 SFPM (2-speed) |
| Cutting Capacity (round) | 4-3/4 in. | 4-3/8 in. |
| Cutting Capacity (rectangular) | 4-3/4 x 4-3/4 in. | 4-3/8 x 4-3/8 in. |
| Weight (bare tool) | 9.6 lbs | 9.0 lbs |
| Battery System | DeWalt 20V MAX / FLEXVOLT | Makita 18V LXT |
| LED Light | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 3 years limited | 3 years limited |
| Best For | Heavy-duty cutting, larger material | Portability, extended runtime |
DeWalt vs Makita Band Saw: Which One Should You Buy?
Both DeWalt and Makita offer excellent cordless band saws that dominate job sites. The DeWalt DCS374B is built for maximum capacity and speed, making it ideal for cutting thicker metal stock and conduit. The Makita XBP04Z focuses on a lighter, more balanced design that reduces fatigue during repetitive cuts. We compared owner reviews, published specs, and brand reliability to give you a clear verdict.
DeWalt DCS374B Deep Dive
The DeWalt DCS374B is a 20V MAX brushless band saw that delivers a class-leading 4-3/4-inch cutting capacity. It features a two-speed gearbox (245 and 295 SFPM) that lets you match speed to material thickness. Owners report that it powers through unistrut, rebar, and schedule 40 pipe with minimal binding.
The tool weighs 9.6 pounds bare, which is noticeable but manageable for short bursts. The integrated LED light illuminates the cut line, and the adjustable shoe helps extend blade life. DeWalt's 3-year limited warranty and extensive service network add peace of mind for professionals.
Makita XBP04Z Deep Dive
The Makita XBP04Z is an 18V LXT brushless band saw that weighs 9.0 pounds bare, making it one of the lightest in its class. It offers a 4-3/8-inch capacity and a two-speed selector (200 and 280 SFPM). The compact design fits into tight spaces where bulkier saws cannot reach.
User reviews consistently praise its balance and low vibration. The tool runs on Makita's proven 18V LXT platform, which offers a huge range of compatible batteries. The variable-speed trigger gives precise control for cutting thin-wall tubing without crushing it. Makita's 3-year warranty covers defects in material and workmanship.
What to Check Before Buying a Band Saw
Before you choose, consider your typical material size. The DeWalt's extra 3/8-inch of capacity matters when cutting larger conduit or stacked materials. Battery ecosystem is also key: if you already own DeWalt 20V or FLEXVOLT batteries, the DCS374B is a natural fit. Makita's 18V LXT line has one of the largest selections of tools, so sticking with that platform saves money on future purchases.
Weight and ergonomics affect daily use. The Makita is half a pound lighter and often feels better balanced due to its compact motor housing. If you make hundreds of cuts per day, that difference adds up. Blade availability is another factor: both brands use standard 44-7/8-inch blades, so replacement blades are easy to find.
Mistakes to Avoid
One common mistake is ignoring the battery requirement. The DeWalt DCS374B is a bare tool; you need a 20V MAX battery (5Ah or higher recommended) and a charger. The Makita XBP04Z also ships as a bare tool. Buying a kit with batteries and charger saves money upfront. Another error is using the wrong blade pitch for the material. Fine-tooth blades (14-18 TPI) work best for thin metal, while coarse blades (10-14 TPI) handle thicker stock. Always match blade speed to the material: use low speed for stainless steel and high speed for mild steel.
DeWalt DCS374B
Largest cutting capacity and fastest speed for heavy-duty metal cutting.
Makita XBP04Z
Best For PortabilityPros
- Lightest in class at 9.0 lbs
- Excellent balance reduces fatigue
- Variable-speed trigger for precision
Cons
- Slightly smaller cutting capacity
- Slower top speed than DeWalt
The Makita XBP04Z is the go-to choice for electricians and plumbers who need a lightweight saw for overhead work or tight spaces. Owner reviews highlight its low vibration and smooth operation, even during extended use. The tool runs on Makita's 18V LXT platform, which is one of the most extensive in the industry.
While it cannot cut as large a pipe as the DeWalt, the 4-3/8-inch capacity still handles most common conduit and rebar sizes. The variable-speed trigger gives you fine control for thin-wall tubing. If you prioritize portability and already own Makita batteries, this is the smarter buy.
DeWalt DCS374B
Best For Heavy DutyPros
- Largest cutting capacity in class
- Fastest top speed for quick cuts
- Adjustable shoe extends blade life
Cons
- Heavier than Makita
- No variable-speed trigger
The DeWalt DCS374B is built for maximum productivity. Its 4-3/4-inch capacity lets you cut larger pipe and stacked materials that the Makita cannot handle. The two-speed gearbox gives you a choice between power and speed, and the 295 SFPM top setting is the fastest in this comparison.
Owner feedback notes that the tool feels solid and cuts aggressively. The LED light is a helpful addition for dim job sites. The main trade-off is weight: at 9.6 pounds, it is heavier than the Makita, and the lack of a variable-speed trigger means less control on thin materials. If you need to cut big stock all day, the DeWalt is the stronger performer.
FAQs
Which band saw is better for cutting stainless steel?
Both saws can cut stainless steel, but the Makita XBP04Z's variable-speed trigger gives better control for thin stainless tubing. Use a fine-tooth blade (14-18 TPI) and low speed for best results.
Can I use DeWalt batteries on a Makita band saw?
No, DeWalt and Makita use incompatible battery platforms. DeWalt uses 20V MAX and FLEXVOLT, while Makita uses 18V LXT. Stick with the brand you already own to avoid buying new batteries.
What is the warranty on DeWalt and Makita band saws?
Both brands offer a 3-year limited warranty covering defects in material and workmanship. DeWalt also provides a 1-year free service contract and a 90-day money-back guarantee.
How long does the battery last on these band saws?
Battery life depends on the material and blade speed. With a 5Ah battery, expect 50-80 cuts through 2-inch steel pipe. Makita's 18V LXT 5Ah battery typically offers slightly longer runtime due to the lower power draw.
Which band saw has a larger cutting capacity?
The DeWalt DCS374B has a larger cutting capacity at 4-3/4 inches round, compared to the Makita XBP04Z's 4-3/8 inches. The extra 3/8 inch matters for cutting larger conduit or stacked materials.
Are these band saws suitable for cutting wood?
These are metal-cutting band saws and are not designed for wood. Using them on wood will dull the blade quickly and may produce unsafe kickback. Use a dedicated wood-cutting bandsaw for lumber.
Do these saws come with a blade?
Both the DeWalt DCS374B and Makita XBP04Z ship as bare tools without a blade. You need to purchase a 44-7/8-inch blade separately. Many users recommend a bi-metal blade for general metal cutting.
Which brand has better customer service?
Both DeWalt and Makita have strong reputations for customer service. DeWalt offers a 1-year free service contract, while Makita provides a 3-year warranty with a network of authorized service centers.
Can I use a 6Ah battery on these saws?
Yes, both saws accept higher-capacity batteries. A 6Ah or 9Ah battery extends runtime significantly. DeWalt's FLEXVOLT batteries also work with the DCS374B for even longer runtimes.
Which band saw is quieter?
Owner reviews indicate the Makita XBP04Z runs slightly quieter due to its lower top speed and balanced motor. Both are brushless, so they are quieter than older brushed models.
Our verdict
For heavy-duty cutting of large pipe and rebar, the DeWalt DCS374B is the best overall band saw due to its larger capacity and faster speed. For portability, comfort, and better battery life, the Makita XBP04Z is the best budget-friendly choice for professionals who need a lightweight tool. Choose based on your primary material size and existing battery platform.