DeWalt vs Makita Pole Saw

DeWalt DCPS620 vs Makita XCU04: Which pole saw is better?

Both DeWalt and Makita offer excellent 8-inch cordless pole saws that are popular among homeowners and professionals. The DeWalt DCPS620 is part of the 20V MAX system and is known for its aggressive cutting speed and durable construction. The Makita XCU04 is part of the 18V LXT platform and is praised for its lighter weight and smoother operation. Owner reviews on Amazon and Home Depot consistently rate both models above 4.4 stars, indicating high satisfaction across the board.

Cutting performance and power

The DeWalt DCPS620 features a chain speed of up to 1,400 SFPM (surface feet per minute), which is significantly faster than the Makita XCU04's 1,180 SFPM. This higher speed allows the DeWalt to cut through thicker, denser branches with less bogging down. Owner reviews frequently mention that the DeWalt cuts through 6-inch limbs effortlessly. The Makita, while slower, is noted for a smoother, more controlled cut that reduces kickback. For heavy pruning of mature trees, the DeWalt has an edge. For general maintenance and lighter trimming, the Makita's performance is more than adequate.

Weight and ergonomics

Weight is a critical factor for a pole saw, as you are often holding it overhead for extended periods. The Makita XCU04 is lighter at 8.8 pounds with a 5Ah battery, compared to the DeWalt DCPS620 at 9.6 pounds. This 0.8-pound difference is noticeable during prolonged use. Owner reviews on the Makita frequently highlight its balance and lighter feel, making it easier to maneuver. The DeWalt, while heavier, has a more robust build and a larger trigger switch that some users find more comfortable with gloves. Both saws have adjustable heads for different cutting angles.

Battery system and compatibility

This is often the deciding factor. The DeWalt DCPS620 uses the 20V MAX battery system, which is compatible with hundreds of other DeWalt tools. It also works with the 60V MAX FlexVolt batteries, which provide extended runtime. The Makita XCU04 uses the 18V LXT system, the largest cordless platform in the world, with over 200 compatible tools. Makita also offers a 36V option using two 18V batteries for more power, but the XCU04 is designed for single battery use. Both brands have excellent battery reliability and availability. If you already own tools from one brand, sticking with that system is the most cost-effective choice.

Build quality and durability

Both DeWalt and Makita are known for their professional-grade build quality. The DeWalt DCPS620 has a metal gear case and a more industrial feel, which contributes to its heavier weight. Owner reviews note that it feels very solid and can withstand drops and rough handling. The Makita XCU04 is also well-built but uses more composite materials to save weight. It still feels durable and is rated for professional use. Both saws come with a 3-year warranty, reflecting the manufacturers' confidence in their products. The DeWalt's chain tensioning system is tool-free and easy to adjust, while the Makita uses a similar system that is also well-regarded.

What to check before buying a pole saw

Before purchasing a cordless pole saw, consider the following factors to ensure you get the right tool for your needs.

• Bar length: 8-inch bars are standard for pole saws and handle most branches up to 6 inches thick. Longer bars exist but can be unwieldy.
• Chain speed: Higher SFPM means faster cuts but can increase kickback risk. Look for a balance of speed and safety features.
• Weight: A lighter saw is easier to use overhead. Consider the weight with the battery included.
• Battery platform: Stick with your existing battery system to save money on extra batteries and chargers.
• Reach: Most pole saws extend from 6 to 10 feet. Ensure the reach is sufficient for your trees.

Mistakes to avoid when choosing a pole saw

Avoid these common pitfalls to ensure you are happy with your purchase.

• Ignoring battery compatibility: Buying a tool from a new platform means investing in batteries and chargers, which can double the cost.
• Choosing based on price alone: Cheaper pole saws often have slower chain speeds and weaker build quality, leading to frustration.
• Overestimating reach: Measure the height of your branches. A standard 8-foot pole may not reach high branches on tall trees.
• Forgetting about maintenance: Pole saws require chain tensioning and lubrication. Choose a model with tool-free adjustments for convenience.