DeWalt vs Makita Saw Horse
Choosing between a DeWalt and a Makita saw horse means weighing durability against portability. We break down the key differences in build, weight capacity, and folding mechanisms to help you decide.
Quick answer
For heavy-duty job site use, the DeWalt DWST11190 wins with its 1,500 lb capacity and robust steel frame. For lightweight portability and quick setup, the Makita 197234-0 is the better choice. The DeWalt is the overall top pick for professional contractors.
Why trust ToolBuyerHub
- Tested on specs (power, torque, PSI)
- Battery & ecosystem compared
- Aggregated owner reviews
- Build quality & warranty checked
- Brand reliability
- No fake hands-on claims
Research updated June 2026.
| Feature | DeWalt DWST11190 | Makita 197234-0 |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Heavy duty / job site | Portability / light work |
| Weight Capacity | 1,500 lbs | 1,100 lbs |
| Weight | 28 lbs | 14.5 lbs |
| Material | Steel frame / plastic top | Aluminum frame / plastic top |
| Folded Size | 37 x 5 x 33 in | 35 x 5 x 28 in |
| Work Surface | 38 x 11 in | 35 x 10 in |
| Leg Lock | Steel locking brackets | Quick-release levers |
| Warranty | 1 year limited | 1 year limited |
| Rating (Amazon) | 4.6 / 5 | 4.5 / 5 |
DeWalt DWST11190 Saw Horse
The DeWalt DWST11190 is a heavy-duty folding saw horse designed for professional contractors who need maximum stability and load capacity. Its steel frame and large plastic top provide a solid work surface for cutting, clamping, and supporting materials.
Owner reviews consistently praise its rock-solid build and high weight limit. Many users note that it does not wobble even under heavy loads, making it ideal for supporting long lumber or heavy doors. The folding mechanism is robust, though the horse is heavy at 28 lbs.
Makita 197234-0 Saw Horse
The Makita 197234-0 is a lightweight aluminum folding saw horse aimed at tradespeople who value portability. At just 14.5 lbs, it is easy to carry between job sites and store in a truck bed or van.
Reviews highlight its quick setup and compact folded size. The quick-release leg locks make deployment fast. However, some users report that the plastic top can flex under very heavy loads, and the 1,100 lb capacity is lower than the DeWalt. It is best for lighter tasks like cutting trim or supporting small projects.
Key Differences Between DeWalt and Makita Saw Horses
The primary difference is material and weight. DeWalt uses a steel frame for maximum durability and a 1,500 lb capacity, while Makita uses aluminum for a lighter, more portable design. The DeWalt is nearly twice as heavy, which adds stability but reduces portability.
Another difference is the leg locking system. DeWalt uses steel locking brackets that are very secure but require more effort to engage. Makita uses quick-release levers that are faster but may not feel as solid over time. Both have a 1-year warranty, but DeWalt's reputation for ruggedness gives it an edge for heavy use.
What to Check Before Buying a Saw Horse
Consider the weight capacity you need. For supporting doors, heavy lumber, or multiple sheets of plywood, a 1,500 lb horse is safer. For light trim work and occasional use, a 1,100 lb horse is sufficient.
Check the folded size and weight. If you carry your saw horse daily, a lighter aluminum model saves energy. If you leave it in a workshop, a heavier steel model offers more stability. Also, look at the work surface size -- larger tops are better for clamping and supporting wide materials.
Mistakes to Avoid When Buying a Saw Horse
One common mistake is buying a horse with too low a weight capacity for your typical tasks. Overloading can cause the horse to collapse or tip, risking injury. Always choose a horse rated for at least 20% more than your heaviest load.
Another mistake is ignoring the leg lock quality. Cheap plastic locks can break over time. Look for metal locking brackets or quick-release levers made of steel or aluminum. Also, avoid models with very narrow legs that may sink into soft ground without a wide foot print.
FAQs
Which saw horse is better for heavy duty use?
The DeWalt DWST11190 is better for heavy duty use due to its 1,500 lb capacity and steel frame.
Is the Makita saw horse portable?
Yes, the Makita 197234-0 is very portable at 14.5 lbs and folds into a compact size for easy transport.
Can I use these saw horses with a workbench?
Yes, both can be used as standalone supports or paired with a workbench for extended work surfaces.
Do these saw horses have a warranty?
Both the DeWalt and Makita saw horses come with a 1-year limited warranty against defects.
Which saw horse has a larger work surface?
The DeWalt has a larger work surface at 38 x 11 inches compared to the Makita's 35 x 10 inches.
Are these saw horses easy to fold?
Yes, both have folding mechanisms. The Makita has quick-release levers for faster folding, while the DeWalt uses steel locking brackets.
Can I use a circular saw on these horses?
Yes, both are suitable for supporting materials while using a circular saw, but ensure the horse is stable and on level ground.
Which brand is more reliable?
Both DeWalt and Makita are reputable brands. DeWalt is known for ruggedness, while Makita is known for innovation and portability.
Do these saw horses come with rubber feet?
Yes, both models include rubber feet to prevent slipping and protect floors.
Can I stack these saw horses for storage?
Yes, both fold flat and can be stacked or hung on a wall for efficient storage.
Our verdict
The DeWalt DWST11190 is the best overall saw horse for heavy duty job site work with its superior 1,500 lb capacity and steel frame. For those who prioritize portability and lighter tasks, the Makita 197234-0 is the best budget-friendly option. Choose based on your weight needs and how often you move your gear.