DeWalt vs Makita Trolley Jack

DeWalt DWST17806 vs Makita MJL-2: Which Trolley Jack Is Right for You?

When you need to lift a vehicle safely and efficiently, the trolley jack is a cornerstone of any workshop. DeWalt and Makita both offer models that promise durability and performance, but they cater to slightly different needs. This comparison looks at published specs, owner reviews from major retailers, and brand reputation to give you an honest assessment.

Key Differences at a Glance

The DeWalt DWST17806 is a 3-ton steel jack with a higher maximum lift, making it ideal for trucks, SUVs, and heavier workshop use. The Makita MJL-2 is a 2.5-ton model with a lower minimum height, perfect for sports cars and low-profile vehicles. The DeWalt is heavier and more robust, while the Makita is lighter and more portable.

Performance and Lifting Power

The DeWalt offers a higher capacity and lift range, which translates to more versatility for larger vehicles. Owner reviews frequently note that the DeWalt lifts smoothly and holds pressure reliably over time. The Makita, while slightly lower in capacity, is often praised for its quick lifting action and ease of use on lower cars. Both use a dual-pump system for faster operation, but the DeWalt's larger frame gives it an edge in stability under heavy loads.

Build Quality and Durability

Both brands are known for robust construction. The DeWalt uses a heavy-duty steel frame with a powder-coated finish that resists rust and chipping. The Makita uses a mix of aluminum and steel, which reduces weight but may not feel as solid over the long term. Aggregated owner feedback suggests the DeWalt has fewer reports of hydraulic leaks after extended use, though both are considered reliable for home and professional use.

Portability and Storage

The Makita MJL-2 is lighter by about 7 pounds and has a more compact footprint, making it easier to move around the garage or take on the road. The DeWalt is heavier and bulkier, but its longer handle provides better leverage and makes rolling it under vehicles easier. If you have limited storage space, the Makita's smaller size is a clear advantage.

What to Check Before Buying a Trolley Jack

Before you choose, consider the types of vehicles you will lift. For sedans and coupes, a low minimum height is critical. For trucks and SUVs, a higher maximum lift and greater capacity are more important. Also check the handle length for comfortable operation and the warranty period for peace of mind. Always verify the jack's weight rating against your vehicle's gross weight.

Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing a Trolley Jack

One common mistake is buying a jack with too low a capacity for your heaviest vehicle. Another is ignoring the minimum height; a jack that is too tall to slide under a low car is useless. Do not overlook the weight of the jack itself, as a very heavy model can be difficult to maneuver. Finally, avoid jacks with short handles, as they require more effort to pump and position.

Ease of Use and Safety

Both jacks feature a safety overload system to prevent lifting beyond rated capacity. The DeWalt has a larger, more comfortable handle grip and a wider base for stability. The Makita is easier to maneuver in tight spaces. Owner reviews on both models mention clear instructions and straightforward operation, with the DeWalt receiving slightly higher marks for build quality and the Makita for portability.

Brand Reliability and Support

DeWalt and Makita are both top-tier brands with extensive service networks. DeWalt offers a 3-year limited warranty on the DWST17806, while Makita provides a 1-year warranty on the MJL-2. DeWalt's longer warranty reflects confidence in the product's durability. Both brands have readily available replacement parts and customer support, though DeWalt's service centers are more numerous in North America.

Which One Should You Buy?

If you work on a variety of vehicles including trucks and SUVs, the DeWalt DWST17806 is the better choice due to its higher capacity, greater lift range, and longer warranty. If you primarily work on low-profile cars or need a lighter jack for portability, the Makita MJL-2 is an excellent option. Both are reliable, but the DeWalt offers more versatility for the money.