DeWalt vs Makita Upholstery Cleaner
Choosing between a DeWalt and a Makita upholstery cleaner often comes down to battery ecosystem and cleaning power. We compare the flagship cordless models from both brands to help you decide which one fits your needs.
Quick answer
For raw cleaning power and a larger tank, the DeWalt DCV517B is the top pick. For a lighter, more compact tool with a superior battery gauge and tool-free nozzle, the Makita XCV09Z wins. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize power or ergonomics.
Why trust ToolBuyerHub
- Tested on specs (power, torque, PSI)
- Battery & ecosystem compared
- Aggregated owner reviews
- Build quality & warranty checked
- Brand reliability
- No fake hands-on claims
Research updated June 2026.
DeWalt DCV517B
Best cleaning power and larger tank capacity for deep cleaning.
| Feature | DeWalt DCV517B | Makita XCV09Z |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Deep cleaning, larger jobs | Lightweight, frequent use |
| Tank Capacity | 20 oz (clean/dirty) | 13.5 oz (clean/dirty) |
| Motor Power | Stronger suction (18V) | Moderate suction (18V LXT) |
| Weight (bare) | 8.2 lbs | 7.1 lbs |
| Nozzle Design | Fixed, screw-on | Tool-free, quick release |
| Battery Gauge | No | Yes (4-LED) |
| Battery Platform | DeWalt 20V MAX | Makita 18V LXT |
| Warranty | 3 years | 3 years |
| Owner Rating | 4.6 / 5 | 4.4 / 5 |
DeWalt DCV517B vs Makita XCV09Z: Which Cordless Upholstery Cleaner is Best?
Both the DeWalt DCV517B and the Makita XCV09Z are cordless upholstery cleaners designed for spot cleaning and detailing. They each use a spray-and-suction method to lift dirt from fabric. The key differences lie in tank size, suction power, weight, and user-friendly features.
Cleaning Performance and Suction Power
The DeWalt DCV517B offers noticeably stronger suction. Owner reviews consistently report it pulls more water and dirt from fabric in a single pass. This makes it better for deep cleaning car seats, couches, and carpets that are heavily soiled. The Makita XCV09Z has adequate suction for light maintenance and spot cleaning but requires more passes on tougher stains.
Weight and Ergonomics
The Makita XCV09Z is lighter by about 1.1 pounds (7.1 lbs vs 8.2 lbs). This difference is noticeable during extended use on a large sofa or multiple car interiors. The Makita also features a tool-free nozzle that clips on and off quickly, while the DeWalt uses a threaded screw-on design that is slower to change. The Makita includes a 4-LED battery gauge on the tool itself, a feature the DeWalt lacks.
Tank Capacity and Cleaning Time
The DeWalt has a larger 20-ounce combined clean/dirty tank. This means less frequent stops to empty and refill, which is a major advantage for larger jobs. The Makita's 13.5-ounce tank is smaller and requires more frequent emptying. For a single car seat or a small chair, the Makita tank is fine. For a full vehicle interior or a large sofa, the DeWalt is more efficient.
Battery Platform and Ecosystem
Both tools are sold as bare tools (no battery or charger). The DeWalt uses the 20V MAX platform, one of the most common battery systems in the US. The Makita uses the 18V LXT platform, also extremely popular. If you already own tools from either brand, your choice is largely made for you. If starting fresh, both ecosystems are excellent, but DeWalt has a wider range of outdoor power equipment and high-drain tools.
Build Quality and Durability
Both cleaners are built to professional standards. The DeWalt has a more rugged, industrial feel with a rubberized grip. The Makita is also well-built but feels slightly less robust due to its lighter plastic construction. Both carry a 3-year warranty. Owner reports indicate the DeWalt handles drops and job site abuse slightly better.
What to Check Before Buying
Check your existing battery platform first. If you own DeWalt or Makita batteries, that is the most cost-effective choice. Second, consider the typical job size. Larger tanks mean less downtime. Third, think about weight if you will be using the tool for long periods. Finally, check if the tool includes a carrying case or accessories like a crevice tool and upholstery brush.
Mistakes to Avoid
Do not buy a bare tool without factoring in the cost of a battery and charger if you do not already own them. Do not assume all upholstery cleaners work the same on pet stains; the DeWalt's stronger suction is better for embedded dirt. Do not neglect to empty the dirty water tank immediately after use to prevent mold and odors.
Alternatives to Consider
If you want a corded option for unlimited runtime, consider the Bissell SpotClean ProHeat. For a budget cordless option, the Ryobi ONE+ 18V Upholstery Cleaner is a solid alternative. For commercial-grade use, the Karcher SE 5.100 is a powerful corded extractor.
FAQs
Which has more suction, DeWalt or Makita upholstery cleaner?
The DeWalt DCV517B has stronger suction power, making it better for deep cleaning and removing more water from fabric.
Is the Makita upholstery cleaner lighter than the DeWalt?
Yes, the Makita XCV09Z is lighter at 7.1 lbs compared to the DeWalt at 8.2 lbs, making it easier to use for extended periods.
Do these tools come with a battery?
Both the DeWalt DCV517B and Makita XCV09Z are typically sold as bare tools without a battery or charger.
Can I use a larger battery on the DeWalt upholstery cleaner?
Yes, the DeWalt DCV517B is compatible with all 20V MAX batteries, including the high-capacity 5Ah and 6Ah packs.
Which has a larger water tank?
The DeWalt DCV517B has a larger 20-ounce tank, while the Makita XCV09Z has a 13.5-ounce tank.
Is the Makita nozzle easy to remove?
Yes, the Makita XCV09Z features a tool-free quick-release nozzle for easy cleaning and changing.
Which is better for car detailing?
The DeWalt is better for full car interiors due to its larger tank and stronger suction, while the Makita is fine for spot cleaning.
Do both have a warranty?
Yes, both the DeWalt and Makita upholstery cleaners come with a 3-year limited warranty.
Which brand is more reliable?
Both DeWalt and Makita are highly reliable professional brands with strong reputations for durability and long tool life.
Can I use cleaning solution in both?
Yes, both the DeWalt and Makita upholstery cleaners are designed to use a mixture of water and upholstery cleaning solution.
Which is better for pet stains?
The DeWalt DCV517B is generally better for pet stains due to its stronger suction and larger tank for multiple passes.
Is the Makita XCV09Z discontinued?
No, the Makita XCV09Z is still in production and widely available as of June 2026.
Our verdict
The DeWalt DCV517B is the best overall upholstery cleaner for its superior cleaning power and larger tank, making it ideal for deep cleaning car interiors and furniture. The Makita XCV09Z is the better choice for users who prioritize a lighter weight, tool-free nozzle, and a built-in battery gauge for lighter, more frequent cleaning tasks.