Yale vs August Video Doorbell

Yale vs August: Which Smart Doorbell Should You Buy?

Both Yale and August are well-known in the smart home space, but they approach video doorbells from different angles. Yale is a trusted name in home security, offering a wired doorbell that prioritizes reliability and local storage. August, now part of the Assa Abloy group, focuses on seamless integration with smart locks and voice assistants. This comparison breaks down the key differences to help you choose the right model for your home.

Video Quality and Field of View

The August Wi-Fi Video Doorbell Pro offers a higher 1536p (2K) resolution, which delivers sharper images than the Yale's 1080p HD. However, the Yale has a wider 180-degree vertical field of view, making it better for seeing packages left at your doorstep. The August has a 140-degree horizontal view, which is standard for most doorbells. In owner reviews, August users often praise the clarity of the video, while Yale owners appreciate the vertical coverage.

Power and Installation

The Yale Video Doorbell is strictly wired, requiring a connection to your existing doorbell transformer (16-24V AC). This ensures constant power but limits placement options. The August doorbell offers more flexibility: it can run on a rechargeable battery or be wired to your existing system. This makes the August a better choice for renters or those without a wired doorbell. Installation for both is straightforward, but the August's battery option eliminates the need for wiring.

Smart Home Ecosystem and Integration

This is where the two differ most. The August doorbell integrates seamlessly with Amazon Alexa, allowing you to view the feed on Echo Show devices and use voice commands. It also supports Apple HomeKit, making it a strong choice for iOS users. The Yale works with both Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, but its integration is less deep. For example, you can view the feed on a Nest Hub, but you cannot use voice commands to lock your door. August's integration with its own smart locks is a major advantage for those building a complete smart entry system.

Storage Options: Local vs. Cloud

Yale offers a significant advantage for privacy-conscious users: local storage via a microSD card (up to 128GB). This means you can store footage without a monthly fee. August relies entirely on cloud storage, which requires a subscription for video recording. The Yale subscription is cheaper at $3.99/month for 30-day video history, while August charges $4.99/month for unlimited recording. Both offer free live viewing and motion alerts without a subscription.

What to Check Before Buying a Video Doorbell

Before purchasing, verify your existing doorbell voltage (16-24V AC is standard for wired models). Check your Wi-Fi signal strength at the door location; a weak signal will cause lag or dropped connections. Consider your smart home ecosystem: if you use Alexa, August is better; if you use Google Assistant, either works. Finally, decide if you want local storage (Yale) or are comfortable with a cloud subscription (August).

Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing a Video Doorbell

A common mistake is buying a wired-only doorbell when you have no existing wiring. Always check your doorbell transformer before buying. Another error is ignoring the field of view: a wide vertical angle is better for seeing packages, while a wide horizontal angle is better for seeing visitors. Finally, do not overlook subscription costs; a doorbell with local storage can save you money over time.

Build Quality and Warranty

Both doorbells are built from durable polycarbonate and are weather-resistant (IP rating not officially stated, but both are rated for outdoor use). The Yale has a slightly more robust feel due to its metal faceplate. The August is lighter but still feels solid. Both come with a 1-year warranty, which is standard for this category. Owner reviews on Amazon report few hardware failures for either brand.

Owner Satisfaction and Reviews

On Amazon, the August Wi-Fi Video Doorbell Pro holds a 4.3 out of 5 rating from over 10,000 reviews. Users frequently praise the video quality and Alexa integration. Common complaints include occasional connectivity issues and the need for a subscription. The Yale Video Doorbell has a 4.1 out of 5 rating from over 5,000 reviews. Users like the local storage and reliable performance, but some find the app less intuitive than August's.

Alternatives to Consider

If neither doorbell fits your needs, consider the Ring Video Doorbell Pro 2 for a wired option with 3D motion detection, or the Arlo Video Doorbell for a wireless model with a wide field of view. For a budget-friendly choice, the Eufy Video Doorbell offers 2K resolution and local storage without a subscription.