DeWalt vs Makita Magnetic Pickup Tool
Dropped a screw or bolt in a tight spot? A magnetic pickup tool is essential. We compare the leading options from DeWalt and Makita based on specs, build quality, and owner feedback.
Quick answer
For most users, the DeWalt DWHT66065 offers the best balance of reach, magnet strength, and price. The Makita A-46389 is a stronger, heavier-duty option for mechanics, but costs more and is less flexible.
Why trust ToolBuyerHub
- Tested on specs (power, torque, PSI)
- Battery & ecosystem compared
- Aggregated owner reviews
- Build quality & warranty checked
- Brand reliability
- No fake hands-on claims
Research updated June 2026.
DeWalt DWHT66065
Best balance of reach, magnet strength, and price.
| Feature | DeWalt DWHT66065 | Makita A-46389 |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | General DIY, tight spaces | Heavy-duty, mechanics |
| Reach | 28 in (flexible) | 20 in (rigid) |
| Magnet Type | Neodymium (rare-earth) | Ceramic (ferrite) |
| Magnet Pull Strength | ~5 lbs (rated) | ~8 lbs (rated) |
| Shaft | Flexible steel cable | Rigid steel rod |
| Handle | Rubber overmold, pocket clip | Plastic, no clip |
| Weight | 0.5 lbs | 0.7 lbs |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime | 1 year limited |
| Rating | 4.7 / 5 | 4.5 / 5 |
| Winner | Best Overall | Strongest Magnet |
DeWalt DWHT66065 Magnetic Pickup Tool Review
The DeWalt DWHT66065 is a 28-inch flexible magnetic pickup tool. It uses a neodymium magnet rated for about 5 pounds of pull. The flexible shaft allows access to tight engine bays, behind appliances, and inside wall cavities. Owner reviews on Amazon and Home Depot highlight its durability and strong hold for its size. The rubber overmold handle provides a secure grip even with oily hands. A pocket clip adds convenience for daily carry.
Makita A-46389 Magnetic Pickup Tool Review
The Makita A-46389 is a 20-inch rigid magnetic pickup tool. It uses a larger ceramic magnet rated for about 8 pounds of pull. This makes it better for retrieving heavier bolts or multiple screws at once. The rigid shaft offers more control for precise retrieval but limits access to curved or angled spaces. Owner reviews mention its solid build and strong pull, but some note the plastic handle feels less premium than the DeWalt. It is heavier and lacks a pocket clip.
Key Differences Between DeWalt and Makita Pickup Tools
The primary difference is flexibility versus raw magnet strength. The DeWalt offers a flexible shaft that can bend into tight, curved spaces. Its neodymium magnet is strong for its size but not as powerful as the Makita's ceramic magnet. The Makita is rigid, limiting access but providing a stronger hold for heavier items. The DeWalt also includes a pocket clip and a more comfortable handle, while the Makita is simpler and more robust for straight-line retrieval.
What to Check Before Buying a Magnetic Pickup Tool
Check the reach length. A 28-inch tool is versatile, but 36-inch options exist for deeper spaces. Consider the magnet strength; 5 pounds is adequate for screws and small bolts, while 8 pounds or more is better for larger hardware. Decide between a flexible shaft for tight corners or a rigid shaft for controlled, straight retrieval. Look for handle comfort and pocket clips for portability. Finally, check warranty and brand reliability.
Mistakes to Avoid When Choosing a Magnetic Pickup Tool
Do not choose a tool based solely on magnet strength. A very strong magnet can be difficult to release from a metal surface. Avoid rigid tools if you need to reach around corners or into curved engine compartments. Do not ignore handle quality; a slippery handle is dangerous near machinery. Also, avoid tools with weak shaft construction that can snap under stress. Finally, do not assume all magnets are the same type; neodymium is more compact, ceramic is heavier but often stronger.
Who Should Buy the DeWalt DWHT66065
The DeWalt is ideal for DIYers, electricians, and mechanics who work in tight, confined spaces. Its flexible shaft is perfect for retrieving screws dropped behind appliances, inside wall cavities, or under car hoods. The pocket clip makes it easy to carry on a tool belt or pocket. It is also a better value for most general-purpose use.
Who Should Buy the Makita A-46389
The Makita is better for heavy-duty use, especially in automotive or industrial settings where you need to retrieve larger bolts or multiple fasteners at once. Its rigid shaft provides more control for precise placement. It is also a good choice if you need a tool that can handle heavier weight without the shaft bending or flexing.
FAQs
Which magnetic pickup tool is stronger, DeWalt or Makita?
The Makita A-46389 has a stronger magnet, rated for about 8 pounds of pull, compared to the DeWalt's 5 pounds.
Can the DeWalt flexible shaft bend around corners?
Yes, the DeWalt DWHT66065 has a flexible steel cable that can bend to access tight, curved spaces.
Is the Makita pickup tool good for mechanics?
Yes, its rigid shaft and strong magnet make it suitable for retrieving bolts and heavy parts in engine bays.
Does the DeWalt pickup tool have a pocket clip?
Yes, the DeWalt DWHT66065 includes a pocket clip for easy carry on a tool belt or pocket.
Which tool is better for DIY home use?
The DeWalt is generally better for DIY due to its flexible shaft, comfortable handle, and lower price.
What is the warranty on the Makita A-46389?
The Makita A-46389 comes with a 1-year limited warranty.
What is the warranty on the DeWalt DWHT66065?
The DeWalt DWHT66065 comes with a limited lifetime warranty.
Can I use a magnetic pickup tool on electronic components?
Use caution as strong magnets can damage sensitive electronics. Neodymium magnets are especially strong.
Which tool is lighter?
The DeWalt DWHT66065 is lighter at 0.5 lbs, while the Makita A-46389 is 0.7 lbs.
Are there longer magnetic pickup tools available?
Yes, both brands offer longer models, such as 36-inch versions, for deeper retrieval needs.
Our verdict
The DeWalt DWHT66065 is the best overall magnetic pickup tool for most users, offering a flexible shaft, strong neodymium magnet, and excellent portability. The Makita A-46389 is the best choice for heavy-duty use where maximum magnet strength and rigid control are required.